The following is a product review of the Align full metal head, including
rotor hub, washout base and arms, mixer arms, flybar hub and cradle.
A very valid question to ask at this point is why this review is covering
all of the upgrade head components in one review rather than separately?
The answer to this is relatively straightforward.
Over the past months I have attempted to review these parts separately
as they were released onto the market. The release of the XL T-Rex caused
a problem with these reviews.The newly released machine had an all-new
head and mixers and the benefits of upgrading to CNC parts in small increments
was extremely hard to quantify for each individual upgrade. The XL was
a step change in quality from the original T-Rex and I therefore decided
that for me to quantify the differences I would need to review the whole
CNC head and make the comparison with an all plastic stock unit.
For those who are currently running the original T-Rex any one of these
upgrades will provide an improvement in flight performance which would
be noticeable for a beginner as well as an expert. However, if you are
an owner of the original T-Rex I would recommend upgrading to the plastic
head and mixers of the XL T-Rex and save yourself some money. Whilst at
the same time significantly improving the flight characteristics of your
machine. The benefits for an XL T-Rex owner are discussed in the conclusion.
With these questions and recommendations complete let's move onto the review
itself by quantifying exactly what components are being reviewed. The pictures
below show the separate packages covered by this article.
Let's look at and talk about these various upgrade parts one at a time
and then look at how they perform when working altogether. Just before
doing that it is worth saying a few words about the quality of these components.
They come in an anodised blue and the metal appears to be of the higher
aircraft grade aluminium which doesn't bend easily. All of the featured
components can be installed as drop-in replacement for the original stock
items. The mixer arms and washout are fully ball raced as is the flybar
hub with the flybar itself running through ball races. The blade grips
are a three bearing design but I was slightly disappointed to only see
radial ball races in the blade grips and no thrust races. Having done some
load calculations it is likely that the ball races in the blade grips may
start to freeze with head speed of 3000 rpm or more. None of these upgrade
parts were either difficult to assemble or problematical to install. All
of them function correctly without modification after installation. When
assembling these parts take care to use loctite on any metal to metal screw
fixing, without this vibration will work screws loose. Any screw coming
loose in the head assembly will result in a crash.
Flybar hub
This is a one-piece unit which basically allows the flybar to run inside
bearings rather than a plastic bushing. The bearings in the hub have a
smaller internal diameter than the original T-Rex flybar and therefore
this unit comes with a new flybar that does fit through these bearings.
This smaller diameter flybar can also be bought separately. Once assembled
the flybar paddles move extremely freely offering very little resistance
to movement. This should allow for finer cyclic control and less strain
on the cyclic servos. It is to the outside of this flybar hub that the
upgrade mixer arms are attached.
Washout arms and mixer arms
The washout arms and mixer arms come as one upgrade to replace both sets of the plastic mixer arms. They come with their own bearings installed. The washout arms need the plastic connectors that go down to the swashplate installed onto them before fitting to the washout hub. The main benefit of these parts is that they are not flexible like the original plastic arms and they also have upgraded bearings. Additionally there is no friction between the CNC mixer arm and the hub. This allows for very free movement and again should improve fine control for both collective and cyclic.
Flybar cradle
This is a CNC exact copy of the T-Rex XL flybar cradle, given the rigidity
of the original cradle I can't see any performance benefit in this particular
part and it's addition to the all metal head in my view is aesthetic.
Rotor hub and washout base
Again these are near identical CNC copies of the original plastic parts,
however, unlike the flybar cradle the rigidity and hardness of these parts
does offer performance benefit. Additionally the precise moulding of these
parts does allow for a very precise match between the anti rotation pin
on the rotor hub and the brass bushed washout base. On the plastic head,
alignment of these pins can be problematical when trying to match to a
metal washout base.
Blades grips
The blade grips are not identical in anyway to the original T-Rex plastic
blade grips, either on the original 450X or the new XL. These new blade
grips feature extra bearings over the stock blade grips and of course their
rigidity helps greatly in areas of blade tracking both whilst in the hover
and also when executing high g-force 3-D. Which can make for much smoother
flight characteristics and elimination of blade flap to some extent. The
blade grips feature radial bearings throughout and therefore I would not
want to push these blade grips beyond 3000 RPM as there is a possibility
of the bearings starting to freeze under load. Ideally a performance blade
grip should include a thrust race which will cope much better with the
forces acting upon it when subjected to the high head speeds often utilised
by 3-D pilots.
Below are some individual pictures of the parts and some assembly pictures showing the whole head.
Build quality
This is always a factor directly related to the cost of the component.
Align upgrade parts are typically cheaper than other after market parts
and this is rarely reflected in the quality of the CNC machining. These
upgrades are no exception to this and I found the quality perfectly acceptable.
Added to this the parts are very nicely anodised in the usual Align light
blue. As previously mentioned I would have preferred to have seen a thrust
race in the blade grips but aside from this the supplied bearings are of
sufficient quality. All of these parts are machined to fit perfectly together
and there should be no issues with misalignment as can be found on some
of the stock plastic parts.
Flight characteristics
Okay, having given a brief overviewof the various components the real question is what impact do these parts
have on the overall flight characteristics of a T-Rex. This is an interesting
debate. I believe that if sufficient time is invested in making sure that
the original T-Rex head and control components can move smoothly and freely
then that T-Rex is capable of hovering just as nicely as one of the later
XL T-Rex. However, once you push into sports flying and then onto 3-D the
differences in quality start to become apparent. The same is true when
looking at the stock plastic XL head in comparison to this CNC head. For
hovering and sports flying you may be hard pressed to tell much difference
between this upgraded head and the original stock plastic one.
The differences become apparent once you move into 3-D. Firstly the CNC
head is far more capable of holding carbon blades in track during violent
3-D moves. This comes across in the behaviour of the helicopter as a much
smoother machine to fly 3-D. As an example when performing a basic forward
flip the CNC head is more likely to complete the flip without deviating
to the left or right.Additionally, it is possible to run higher head speed and still have the
blades track perfectly. This was best proved using a set of Align carbon
blades that I know do not track well when fitted to a plastic stock head.
They were significantly better on the CNC head.
One other notable improvement was that in high collective manoeuvres (such
as tic-tocs) the overall collective response was more crisp than when using
the stock plastic head.
Overall conclusion
As always Align have produced some very nice upgrades for the head components
of their T-Rex and have very much set the standard for other aftermarket
manufacturers (who may charge more for their parts than Align). Align are
definitely making the upgrade market a very competitive place.
The question is whether the expense of an all metal CNC head and components
is worth the investment given the level of benefit that it may offer. In
this regard I would have difficulty recommending this level of upgrade
for anyone who is not capable of 3-D flight. Whilst these upgrades do definitely
improve the flight characteristics of the T-Rex, beginner or sport fliers
would not push the machine hard enough to exploit the potential of these
upgrades or reap the benefits.
This of course doesn't take into account that the prospective buyer may
be upgrading because they like the look of these parts rather than needing
the performance benefit they may offer. Many upgrade items such as this
are bought as much for looks as they are for perfromance.
For the ardent 3-D flyer it is a different argument. Personally I like
my machine to be as predictable as possible when being pushed through 3-D
manoeuvres. This is where these upgrades offer the most benefit. After
fitting these upgrade parts I feel much more confident that my T-Rex will
go where I point it during a 3-D maneuver rather than keeping me on my
toes wondering if it is going to do something unexpected. This inspires
confidence and I have found that my own 3-D repertoire with the T-Rex has
expanded closer to what I can do with a larger nitro machine as a result.
The decision to buy is very much a matter of personal choice. The stock
XL T-Rex is very capable of performing as a 3-D machine without upgrades.
These upgrades do not make the T-Rex any more capable. What they do provide
is a more locked in 3-D performance. The personal choice is how highly
you value the confidence this will give you in your machine over the dent
it will place in your wallet. For me it was a price worth paying as I purchased
every one of the components reviewed here rather than them being supplied
as review items. The extra confidence they have inspired was worth the
financial outlay. Of course this equation may not balance for everyone.
Discuss this review in the TrexTuning forum by clicking here.
If you own these products then please rate them using the TRexTuning rating
system .......